Thursday, October 29, 2009

drivers license - refusal to take chemical test - knowing refusal - influence of prescr. drug and head injury

Sitoski v. PennDOT - Cmwlth. Court - October 29, 2009

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/431CD09_10-29-09.pdf

If a licensee takes a prescription drug, knowing its side effects, and then sustains a head injury in an accident, the licensee can establish an inability to make a knowing and conscious refusal by presenting expert medical testimony that the head injury played a greater role in the refusal than the prescription drug.

Here, the licensee presented medical testimony, but not about whether licensee’s closed-head injury played a greater role than the prescription sleep medication in his inability to make a knowing and conscious refusal. The doctor testified only that the sleep medication in combination with the closed-head injury made licensee unable to make a knowing and conscious refusal. The suspension, therfore, was proper.
__._,_.___