Iannoco v. Fuelin Fine Auto Sales – 59
Northampton 689
Appeal
from MDJ money judgment filed by a corporate agent or office is a ineffective,
a legal “nullity,” since a corporation can act in court only through
counsel. Petition to strike appeal granted.
In Pennsylvania, “a corporation may
appear and be represented in our courts only by an attorney duly admitted to
practice” law. Walacavage v. Excell 2000, Inc., 480 A.2d 281, 285 (Pa. Super.
1984). There are only two exceptions to this rule, and neither is applicable
here. First, a corporation does not require an attorney if permitted to
represent itself by rule or statute. Id. at 284. There are no such rules or
statutes applicable here. n. 2
When a corporation files an appeal to
the Court of Common Pleas without an attorney, the filing is a nullity,
rendering the Court without jurisdiction to hear it and requiring the Court to
strike the appeal. See Spirit of the Avenger Ministries v. Commw., 767 A.2d
1130, 1130-31 (Pa. Commw. 2001); see also McCain v. Curione, 527 A.2d 591, 594
(Pa. Commw. 1987) (agreeing with two Courts of Common Pleas that “proceedings
commenced by persons unauthorized to practice law are a nullity”).
n.
2
While Pa.R.C.P.M.D.J. No. 207(A)(3)
authorizes a corporation to be represented by an officer, employee, or
authorized agent of the corporation in magisterial district court proceedings,
there is no Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure that authorizes the same in an
appeal from such a proceeding or in a civil action before the Court of Common
Pleas. Further, while Plaintiff argues that the holding in Harkness v.
Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 920 A.2d 162 (Pa. 2007) carved out
an applicable exception to the general rule, the Court disagrees. In that case,
the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a nonattorney representative is
permitted to represent a corporate employer in unemployment compensation
proceedings before a referee for reasons peculiar to those proceedings. Id. at
168-69. None of the reasons cited by the court in Harkness apply with regard to
a civil action before the Court of Common Pleas