Wednesday, October 22, 2008

civil procedure - POs - failure to respond

Joloza v. PennDOT - Cmwlth. Court - October 23, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/485CD08_10-22-08.pdf

It was error fro the trial court to sustain the defendant's preliminary objections (demurrer) solely on the basis of plaintiff's failure to respond to the POs, without even considering the allegations in the plaintiff's complaint.

UC - "unemployed"

Scott v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 21, 2008 - unreported memorandum opinion

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/305CD08_10-21-08.pdf

School employee was not "unemployed" under 43 PS sec. 753(u) and 801 where she continued to receive wages and health benefits under a collective barg. agreement during a period in which she was not working, over the summer.

custody - public schooling v. home schooling - no presumption

Staub v. Staub - Superior Court - October 21, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/A13018_08.pdf

The court rejected father's request that it "adopt a clear but narrow rule that requires children to attend public schools when parents who share legal custody cannot agree on home schooling versus public schooling. We decline to adopt such a rule or presumption. To the contrary, we hold that the well-established best interests standard, applied on a case by case basis, governs a court’s decision regarding public schooling versus home schooling."

Monday, October 20, 2008

UC - appellate brief - no case citations; willful misconduct

Miracle v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 20, 2008 - unreported memorandum decision

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/250CD08_10-20-08.pdf

appellate brief - Rule 2101 - no case citations -The court refused to quash claimant's brief, even though it did not contain any case citations. The court found that the "argument articulated are sufficient to allow the court to engage in appellate review.

willful misconduct - Claimant's failure to comply with the employer's reasonable work request (entering an incident in a master log) was reasonable, and that claimant's failure to do so, without good cause, constituted willful misconduct.

Friday, October 17, 2008

disability - mental impairment - severity

Velazquez v. Astrue - ED Pa. - October 2008

http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/08D1220P.pdf

Finding of non-severity of mental impairment not supported by substantial evidence. Case remanded.

" In order to meet the step two severity test, an impairment need only cause a slight abnormality that has no more than a minimal effect on the ability to do basic work activities. 20 C.F.R. §§ 404.1521, 416.921; S.S.R. 96-3p, 85-28. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has held that the step two severity inquiry is a “de minimus screening device to dispose of groundless claims.” McCrea v. Comm. of Soc. Sec., 370 F.3d 357, 360 (3d Cir. 2004); Newell v. Comm. of Soc. Sec., 347 F.3d 541, 546 (3d Cir. 2003). “Any doubt as to whether this showing has been made is to be resolved in favor of the applicant.” Id.

The medical records from 2000 and 2001 show serious symptoms and limitations arising from Velazquez’s mental impairment including GAF scores between 45 and 58....Although the ALJ listed most of the evidence, she did not mention the GAF scores or sufficiently explain why the state medical consultant’s conclusion of non-severity was most consistent with the evidence, especially in light of the many serious findings from Velazquez’s treating and examining mental health professionals.

While the evidence may not establish disabling depression, the evidence also does not appear to establish that Velazquez’s depression was groundless. As a result, on remand, the ALJ shall re-assess her determination regarding Velazquez’s depression and support her decision with substantial evidence. Likewise, the ALJ shall conform her RFC assessment and any hypothetical questions to reflect her properly supported conclusions.

evidence - clear and convincing evidence

Kistler v. State Ethics Commission - Cmwlth. Court - October 17, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/1352CD07_10-17-08.pdf

" Clear and convincing proof is evidence that is so clear, direct, weighty and convincing that it enables the trier of fact to come to a clear conviction, without hesitance, of the truth of the precise facts in issue. In re Adoption of Charles E.D.M., 550 Pa. 595, 708 A.2d 88 (1998)."

Thursday, October 16, 2008

UC- willful misconduct

Keystone Central School District v. UCBR - Cmwlth./ Court - October 15, 2008 - unreported en banc memorandum opinion (5-2)

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/1864CD07_10-15-08.pdf

Learning support teacher was not guilty of willful misconduct for her conduct during testing of learning disabled students. The UCBR's findings that her actions were consistent with state exam testing accommodations, each child's IEP, and instructions from her superiors were supported by substantial evidence.

paternity by estoppel

Ellison v. Lopez - Superior Court - October 15, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/a18031_08.pdf

Defendant estopped from denying paternity of child born out of wedlock where

- there was no fraud or misrepresentation by mother

- defendant was always aware that there was a question about paternity

- defendant held child out as his own and assumed parental role for at least two years, despite paternity questions

- defendant did not ask for paternity testing for two years, despite child's lack of resemblance to him

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

UC - appeal - notice of issues - timeliness of appeal

Plut v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 14, 2008 - unreported memorandum decision

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/2283CD07_10-14-08.pdf

Issue of timeliness of claimant's appeal was properly considered, even though not listed on the notice of hearing.

The referee gave claimant the option of continuing the hearing because the issue was not listed, but not the "chance to refused to decide the timeliness issue" under 34 Pa. Code101.87. http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/034/chapter101/s101.87.html.

Nonetheless, following Dilenno v. UCBR, 429 A.2d 1288 (Pa. Cmwlth 1288, 1289 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1981), the court said the timeliness of an appeal is a jurisdictional prerequisite that is always at issue, cannot be waived by the referee by the failure to list it on the notice of hearing, and can be raised by the court on its own motion at any time.

UC- vol. quit - good cause - change in work schedule

Philadelphia Park Casino v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 14, 2008 - unreported memorandum decision

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/726CD08_10-14-08.pdf

Claimant had good cause to quit his job where he has negotiated a work shedule with the employer, for religious and health reasons, and employer unilaterally changed the schedule.

UC - hearing - continuance - good cause - new job

Ammon v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 14, 2008 - unreported memorandum decision

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/795CD08_10-14-08.pdf

Refusal to grant claimant's last minute request for a continuance was an abuse of discretion, where it resulted from an unexpected, last-minute opportunity to begin employment on the day of the hearing.

Normally, last-minute requests are disfavored. However, in this case the request was supported by "proper cause" under 34 Pa. Code § 101.23 http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/034/chapter101/s101.23.html.

The refusal to grant it would penalize a person who actually found work and would be "contrary to the goal of stabilizing employment." Shegan v. UCBR, 564 A.2d 1022, 1025 n. 5 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1989).

pre-emption - state/local

Hoffman Mining Company v. Zoning Hearing Board - Cmwlth. Court - October 15, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/2122CD07_10-15-08.pdf

Whether a state statute preempts local regulation is determined by the intent of the General Assembly. The General Assembly can specifically express its intent by either providing that municipalities may enact ordinances not inconsistent with state law, limiting what subjects of regulation that may be enacted, or by expressly forbidding municipal regulation altogether.

However, the General Assembly is often silent and is not presumed to have preempted the field by legislating in it; therefore, it must clearly be shown that it was the General Assembly’s intent to preempt the field by legislation. Retail Master Bakers Association v. Allegheny County, 400 Pa. 1, 161 A.2d 36 (1960); Baird v. Township of New Britain, 633 A.2d 225 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1993).

The presumption against preemption is based on the understanding that what is being preempted is the ability of the municipality, through its elected local officials, to address the needs of its citizens.

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

UC - willful misconduct - lateness

Turner v. UCBR - Cmwlth. Court - October 8, 2008 - unreported memorandum decision

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/519CD08_10-8-08.pdf

Claimant was guilty of willful misconduct when she stopped on her way to work to get shoes (because her feet hurt), without telling the employer that she was doing so and would be late. Claimant had a history of lateness and had been given a final warning.

child abuse - "imminent risk" - OCYF Bulletin

Montgomery Co. CYS v. DPW - Cmwlth. Court - Octobwer 8, 2008 - unreported memorandum opinion

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/376CD08_10-8-08.pdf

No risk of imminent serious injury by momentary inattention of daycare worker, especially considering the definition of "imminent risk" in proposed regs.

Monday, October 06, 2008

disability - treating physician opinion; credibility

Wilson v. Astrue - ED Pa. November 28, 2007

http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/07D1402P.pdf

Benefits granted in this case, with good discussions of standards for evaluating opinion of treating physician and judging claimant credibility.

Sunday, October 05, 2008

appellate rules - petitioner for allowance of appeal - PRAP 1115

order - http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/196aplt.1.pdf

rule - http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/196aplt.1attach.pdf

evidence - offers to compromise - Pa. R. Evid. 408

http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/451spct.1attach.pdf

http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/451spct.1rpt.pdf

http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/451spct.1.pdf

UC - vol. quit - intolerable conditions - unjust accusations

First Federal Savings Bank v. UCBR - Commonwealth Court - October 2, 2008

http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/427CD08_10-2-08.pdf

Held that claimant had good cause/necessitour & compelling reason to quit her job, where

- she was a valued management employeee

- a fellow employee “engaged in outbursts, was talking, defiant and argumentative, and was quite disrespectful to the claimant personally.”

- claimant expressed her concerns about this to senior management, who did not do anything about it

- claimant established that “1) circumstances existed which produced real and substantial pressure to terminate employment; 2) like circumstances would compel a reasonable person to act in the same manner; 3) she acted with ordinary common sense; and 4) she made a reasonable effort to preserve her employment.”

- She had ‘good cause’ for voluntarily leaving (i.e. that cause which is necessitous and compelling) resulting from circumstances which produced pressure to terminate employment that was both real and substantial, and which would compel a reasonable person under the circumstances to act in the same manner.”

- "Perhaps most important to the present case, it is well established that “a claimant need not indefinitely subject herself to unjust accusations and abusive conduct.” However, “[r]esentmentof a reprimand, absent unjust accusations, profane language or abusive conduct …mere disappointment with wages … and personality conflicts, absent intolerable working atmosphere … do not amount to necessitous and compelling causes.”

- Claimant demonstrated more than a mere belief of unjust accusations, as the Board concluded that Claimant was, in fact, unjustly reprimanded with abusive language and that Claimant was subjected to intolerable working conditions.

- Claimant made attempts on various occasions to preserve her employment relationship with Employer without success. Claimant took her concerns to senior management officials and was reasonable in doing so

Friday, September 26, 2008

consumer - UTPCPL - fraud in the inducement - parol evidence

Devine v. America's Whole Lender, et al. - ED Pa. - September 25, 2008

http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/08D1132P.pdf

Plaintiff's evidence about defendant's preliminary, fraudulent misrepresentations is barred by the Pennsylvania application of the parol evidence rule barring evidence about fraud in the inducement.

From the opinion (read it and weep)

Under Pennsylvania law, evidence of prior or contemporaneous oral or written negotiations or agreements is generally inadmissible to explain or vary the terms of a contract that covers or purports to cover the entire agreement of the parties. Yocca v. The Pittsburgh Steelers Sports, Inc., 854 A.2d 425, 436 (Pa. 2004); Bardwell v. Willis Co., Inc., 100 A.2d 102, 104 (Pa. 1953). In Yocca, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court explained the fraud exception to the parol evidence rule as follows:

"Notably, while parol evidence may be introduced based on a party's claim that there was fraud in the execution of the contract, i.e., that a term was fraudulently omitted from the contract, parol evidence may not be admitted based on a claim that there was fraud in the inducement of the contract, i.e., that an opposing party made false representations that induced the complaining party to agree to the contract. Yocca, 854 A.2d at fn. 26; see also HCB Contractors v. Liberty Place Hotel Assocs., 652 A.2d 1278, 1279 (Pa. 1995)."

The plaintiffs claim they signed the loan documents based on defendant's assurances that the payment option they desired would be added to the package after execution of the documents. This is fraud in the inducement. The parol evidence rule bars the introduction of this evidence because plaintiffs seek to vary the terms of the written loan documents, which purported to cover the parties' entire agreement. There is no evidence that a term was fraudulently omitted from the contract. Thus, what happened here does not fall within the fraud exception under Yocca.

Given Pennsylvania's adoption of the parol evidence rule, the plaintiffs cannot be said to have justifiably relied on the defendants' representations regarding the amount of the monthly payments due under the loans because these representations are in direct conflict with the parties' contract. Yocca, 854 A.2d at 502. Thus, plaintiffs' claim under the UTPCPL fails.

Accordingly, the court will grant summary judgment on plaintiffs' claims under the catch-all provision of the UTPCPL which are based on defendants' alleged misrepresentations.6

n. 6 - The plaintiffs' brief in opposition to the defendants' motion for summary judgment for the first time asserts that their claims "are based in part on the ground that a violation of any portion of the UTPCPL, notably here the violations of 73 P.S. section 201-7 and the violation of any other consumer protection laws, such as the TILA, constitute per se violations of section 201-4(2) of the TPCPL." However, paragraph 32 of the plaintiffs' complaint premises their per se violations of the UTPCPL on the defendants' alleged violations of the Pa. Credit Services Act and the Pa. Loan Broker Trade Practices Regulations ("LBTP") only. To the extent the plaintiffs have premised their claims under the UTPCPL on the alleged violations of TILA and § 201-7 of the UTPCPL, such claims come too late.

child abuse - founded report - right to hearing

G.M. v. DPW - Commonwealth Court - September 26, 2008

http://origin-www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Cwealth/out/765CD08_9-26-08.pdf

There is no right to a civil expungment hearing on a "founded" report of abuse--i.e., one based on a court decision-- where the defendant has previously pleaded nolo contendere in a separate criminal case, if the same underlying factual circumstances are involved in both matters.

The court contrasted its decision in R.F. v. DPW, 845 A.2d 214 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2004), where the generic criminal charges did not correspond to the allegations of abuse in the civil case.

Where “there is an entry of a guilty plea or nolo contendere or a finding of guilt to a criminal charge involving the same factual circumstance involved in the allegation of child abuse, an appeal would ‘in most instances, constitute a collateral attack of the adjudication itself, which is not allowed.’” J.G. v. DPW, 795 A.2d 1089, 1093 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2002).