Turner v. Hershey Chocolate - 3d Cir. - March 20, 2006
http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/044674p.pdf
Plaintiff's Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) claims, 42 USC 12112(a), et al., were not estopped by allegations in her SSDI and long-term disability insurance claims about her disability.
Statements in support of an SSDI claim do no take into account the concept of reasonable accommodation under the ADA and therefore do not necessarily estop a claim under the ADA that one is capable of performing the essential functions of a job, with reasonable accommodations. Cleveland v. Policy Mgmt. Systems Corp., 526 US 795 (1999)
Statements on the long-term disability insurance claim were not categorical statements of total inability to peform job funcionts, nor did they take into account plaintiff's ADA entitlement to reasonable accommodation.
Friday, March 24, 2006
custody - relocation - intrastate
Speck v. Spadafore - Superior Court - March 22, 1006
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/A05024_06.pdf
Unmarried parents had 9 y/o child. A York County order was entered giving parties shared legal custody, mother primary physical custody, and father partial custody, with almost daily contact. In 2005 mother filed a petition to modify to allow her to relocate with the child to Butler County, near Pittsburgh, in light of her impending marriage. The trial court granted mother's motion and gave father partial custody during most of the summer.
The appellate court found that the "trial court focused on Mother's personal happiness to the virtual exclusion of the other relevant facts," in spite of its finding that the current arrangement was working well for the child, including almost daily contact with the father and the fact that all extended family from both sides live in the Harrisburg area, within 10 minutes of both parties' homes.
The court said that it was "clear that the only improvement is in Mother's personal relationship" and that the "detriments were numerous and significant," including the "disruption of [the father-child] relationship" and the separation of the child from two half-siblings -- the children of father and his girlfriend, who have lived together for 6 years. Quoting Jane Austen's Mansfield Park, the court said that "children of the same family, the same blood, with the same associations and habits, have some means of enjoyment in their power, which no subsequent connections can supply....' Relocation cases have highlighted the enduring value of the maintenance of sibling relationships."
"While relocation may enhance Mother's own personal and emotional happiness and well-being, our concern must be centered upon whether the move is in the child's best interest....[T]he custody parent bears the burden of establishing a significant improvement in the quality of life for that parent and child...We can identify no significant benefits of relocation to the child in the instant case. The reality is that [the child] enjoyed a good quality of life, surrounded by loving parents, siblings, extended family, a sound school, a circle of friends, and extracurricular activities."
The only benefit identified to mother was her relationship with her new husband. This "relocation had one goal, Mother's cohabitation with the man she intended to marry...[T]hat one fact, alone, is simply not enough to require a ten year-old child to relinquish his parental and familial supports, the very relationships that will enrich and sustain him as he grows to adulthood."
The opinion contains a complete statement of its scope and standard of review, along with the factors relevant to a relocation case.
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/A05024_06.pdf
Unmarried parents had 9 y/o child. A York County order was entered giving parties shared legal custody, mother primary physical custody, and father partial custody, with almost daily contact. In 2005 mother filed a petition to modify to allow her to relocate with the child to Butler County, near Pittsburgh, in light of her impending marriage. The trial court granted mother's motion and gave father partial custody during most of the summer.
The appellate court found that the "trial court focused on Mother's personal happiness to the virtual exclusion of the other relevant facts," in spite of its finding that the current arrangement was working well for the child, including almost daily contact with the father and the fact that all extended family from both sides live in the Harrisburg area, within 10 minutes of both parties' homes.
The court said that it was "clear that the only improvement is in Mother's personal relationship" and that the "detriments were numerous and significant," including the "disruption of [the father-child] relationship" and the separation of the child from two half-siblings -- the children of father and his girlfriend, who have lived together for 6 years. Quoting Jane Austen's Mansfield Park, the court said that "children of the same family, the same blood, with the same associations and habits, have some means of enjoyment in their power, which no subsequent connections can supply....' Relocation cases have highlighted the enduring value of the maintenance of sibling relationships."
"While relocation may enhance Mother's own personal and emotional happiness and well-being, our concern must be centered upon whether the move is in the child's best interest....[T]he custody parent bears the burden of establishing a significant improvement in the quality of life for that parent and child...We can identify no significant benefits of relocation to the child in the instant case. The reality is that [the child] enjoyed a good quality of life, surrounded by loving parents, siblings, extended family, a sound school, a circle of friends, and extracurricular activities."
The only benefit identified to mother was her relationship with her new husband. This "relocation had one goal, Mother's cohabitation with the man she intended to marry...[T]hat one fact, alone, is simply not enough to require a ten year-old child to relinquish his parental and familial supports, the very relationships that will enrich and sustain him as he grows to adulthood."
The opinion contains a complete statement of its scope and standard of review, along with the factors relevant to a relocation case.
Pennsylvania Bulletin of March 25, 2006
Here's the link http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/index.html
Of possible interest-
- court rules - support - proposed rules
comments due May 12, 2006
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/480.html
- court rules - PFA - proposed rules
comments due May 12, 2006
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/479.html
- voter i.d. - Governor's veto of HB 1318
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/475.html
- damages - limitation - contractors - construction defect - dwelling- AG opinion - HB 1467
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/476.html
- MDJs - training and certification
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/478.html
- client security fund - attorneys - discipline
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/477.html
Of possible interest-
- court rules - support - proposed rules
comments due May 12, 2006
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/480.html
- court rules - PFA - proposed rules
comments due May 12, 2006
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/479.html
- voter i.d. - Governor's veto of HB 1318
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/475.html
- damages - limitation - contractors - construction defect - dwelling- AG opinion - HB 1467
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/476.html
- MDJs - training and certification
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/478.html
- client security fund - attorneys - discipline
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-12/477.html
Monday, March 20, 2006
SSA Issues New Rules on Medical Equivalence in Disability Determinations
The Social Security Administration has published final rules revising the the processing of claims for disability benefits under Titles II and XVI of the Social Security Act. These revisions make the language in the rules used under Title II for making findings about medical equivalence consistent with the language in the rules used under Title XVI of the Act.
The revisions also clarify SSA's rules about the evidence used to making findings about medical equivalence for adults and children. The rules explaining the Listing of Impairments and how impairment(s) can meet a listing are also updated and clarified.The new rules will be effective on March 31, 2006.
Final Rules
The revisions also clarify SSA's rules about the evidence used to making findings about medical equivalence for adults and children. The rules explaining the Listing of Impairments and how impairment(s) can meet a listing are also updated and clarified.The new rules will be effective on March 31, 2006.
Final Rules
Friday, March 17, 2006
Pennsylvania Bulletin of March 18, 2006
Here's the link http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/index.html
Of possible interest-
- evidence - Rule 404 - character evidence - not admissible generally - exceptions
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/419.html
- courts - judicial discipline court - internal operating procedure
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/418.html
- Commonwealth Court - sessions for 2007
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/422.html
- local courts rules - - custody - pretrial conferences
Westmoreland County http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/421.html
Northampton Copunty http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/420.html
- welfare - payments to nursing facilities - final rates 2005-6
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/448.html
- welfare - peer groups - nursing and special rehab facilities
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/449.html
Of possible interest-
- evidence - Rule 404 - character evidence - not admissible generally - exceptions
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/419.html
- courts - judicial discipline court - internal operating procedure
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/418.html
- Commonwealth Court - sessions for 2007
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/422.html
- local courts rules - - custody - pretrial conferences
Westmoreland County http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/421.html
Northampton Copunty http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/420.html
- welfare - payments to nursing facilities - final rates 2005-6
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/448.html
- welfare - peer groups - nursing and special rehab facilities
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-11/449.html
Thursday, March 16, 2006
disability - depression/alcoholism - prescribed treatment
Bodner v. Barnhart - ED Pa. - March 14, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0316P.pdf
Alcohol/depression case. Case remanded where
a) There was no evidence in the record that claimant could work when sober and compliant with medications. There was no support in the medical record for this finding, since claimant had not been directed to take psychotropic drugs. A claimant needn't take palliative drugs unless prescribed. The ALJ impropely ignored the treating physician's opinions in this regard.
b) The ALJ did not follow the procedure in SSR 82-59 concerning failure to follow prescribed treatment.
Some key facts -
- Claimant (CL) testified that he had been sober since April 2002
- Treating psych. said CL couldn't complete normal work day/week
- VE testified that CL couldn't do any work if unable to complete normal work day/week
- No psychotropic meds prescribed because of CL's liver disease and other health problems
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0316P.pdf
Alcohol/depression case. Case remanded where
a) There was no evidence in the record that claimant could work when sober and compliant with medications. There was no support in the medical record for this finding, since claimant had not been directed to take psychotropic drugs. A claimant needn't take palliative drugs unless prescribed. The ALJ impropely ignored the treating physician's opinions in this regard.
b) The ALJ did not follow the procedure in SSR 82-59 concerning failure to follow prescribed treatment.
Some key facts -
- Claimant (CL) testified that he had been sober since April 2002
- Treating psych. said CL couldn't complete normal work day/week
- VE testified that CL couldn't do any work if unable to complete normal work day/week
- No psychotropic meds prescribed because of CL's liver disease and other health problems
consumer - predatory lending - statute of limitations - equit. tolling - discovery rule
Wise v. Mortgage Lenders Network USA - ED Pa. - March 13, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0317P.pdf
Lender and mortgage broker moved to dismiss various consumer claims under Rule 12(b)(6) based on statute of limitations grounds. Motion denied.
equitable tolling
Dismissal of federal statutory claims was denied under equitable tolling doctrine, because the complaint alleged that the defendants had actively misled the plaintiffs about their claims. The "doctrine of 'equitable tolling' operates to stop the statute of limitations from running whete the claim's actual accrual date has alreayd passed...It thus allows a court 'to extend a statute of limitations on a case-by-case basis to prevent inequity." Fraudulent concealment was alleged, and plaintiffs showed that they had exercised reasonable diligence in investigating and bringing the claims. Plaintiffs' complaint alleged "facts that suggest an active attempt....to intentionally defraud them by exploiting their financial need and concealing material terms of the loan.
discovery rule
Dismissal of state fraud and breach of fiduciary claim was similarly rejected by application of the "'discovery rule' exception to the statute of limitations which delays the running of the statute until the plaintiff knew, or through the exercise of reasoanble diligence should have known, of the injury and its cause....[W]hen the underlying events being sued upon sound inherently in fraud or deceit...that, without more, will toll the statute of limitations until such time as the fraud has been revealed, or should have been revealed by the exercise of due diligence by the plaintiff.'"
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0317P.pdf
Lender and mortgage broker moved to dismiss various consumer claims under Rule 12(b)(6) based on statute of limitations grounds. Motion denied.
equitable tolling
Dismissal of federal statutory claims was denied under equitable tolling doctrine, because the complaint alleged that the defendants had actively misled the plaintiffs about their claims. The "doctrine of 'equitable tolling' operates to stop the statute of limitations from running whete the claim's actual accrual date has alreayd passed...It thus allows a court 'to extend a statute of limitations on a case-by-case basis to prevent inequity." Fraudulent concealment was alleged, and plaintiffs showed that they had exercised reasonable diligence in investigating and bringing the claims. Plaintiffs' complaint alleged "facts that suggest an active attempt....to intentionally defraud them by exploiting their financial need and concealing material terms of the loan.
discovery rule
Dismissal of state fraud and breach of fiduciary claim was similarly rejected by application of the "'discovery rule' exception to the statute of limitations which delays the running of the statute until the plaintiff knew, or through the exercise of reasoanble diligence should have known, of the injury and its cause....[W]hen the underlying events being sued upon sound inherently in fraud or deceit...that, without more, will toll the statute of limitations until such time as the fraud has been revealed, or should have been revealed by the exercise of due diligence by the plaintiff.'"
Tuesday, March 14, 2006
custody - relocation - no prior custody order
Collins v. Collins - Superior Court - March 13, 2006
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/s62032_05.pdf
Trial court's order denying mother's request to relocate was reversed on appeal.
Relocation -- The Gruber factors, while important, are but one aspect of the overall best interest analysis; they "take into account only...a small corner of the best interest cosmos." Where there is no existing prior order, it is error to place a higher burden on the relocating parent and to decide relocation first, then primary custody. "Nothing in our case law suggests that...where primary custody must be decided in the context of a relocation request, relocation should take a place of prominence and be the subject of an initial decision, which then leads inexorably to the custody decision....The focus of the court must be on determining which parent and which living situation provides a familial setting that better serves the children's best interests."
Stability -- Stability is important, but physical stability, i.e., staying in the same home, is just one factor. "A child's sense of stability involves more than just physical structures and location; stability with regard to caregiver and patterns of car must also be considered."
Primary caretaker - age of children -- Primary caretaker is an important factor no matter what the children's ages. There is "no support in the case law" for a contrary notion, which the lower court expressed.
Disposition - The appellate court has the option to decide the case on the merits where the record is sufficiently developed.
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/s62032_05.pdf
Trial court's order denying mother's request to relocate was reversed on appeal.
Relocation -- The Gruber factors, while important, are but one aspect of the overall best interest analysis; they "take into account only...a small corner of the best interest cosmos." Where there is no existing prior order, it is error to place a higher burden on the relocating parent and to decide relocation first, then primary custody. "Nothing in our case law suggests that...where primary custody must be decided in the context of a relocation request, relocation should take a place of prominence and be the subject of an initial decision, which then leads inexorably to the custody decision....The focus of the court must be on determining which parent and which living situation provides a familial setting that better serves the children's best interests."
Stability -- Stability is important, but physical stability, i.e., staying in the same home, is just one factor. "A child's sense of stability involves more than just physical structures and location; stability with regard to caregiver and patterns of car must also be considered."
Primary caretaker - age of children -- Primary caretaker is an important factor no matter what the children's ages. There is "no support in the case law" for a contrary notion, which the lower court expressed.
Disposition - The appellate court has the option to decide the case on the merits where the record is sufficiently developed.
Monday, March 13, 2006
due process - post-hearing addition to order
In re D.G. - Superior Court - March 10, 2006
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/s67030_05.pdf
Appellant/father's due process rights were violated when the court in a dependency case added a provision to its order, ex parte, after the hearing, without giving father notice or an opportunity to be heard on the issue. The addition was a no-contact order concerning one of the witnesses.
An ex parte injunction can issue on where it is evident from the record that there would be immediate and irreparable injury if the injunction were delayed until notice could be given and a hearing held. There was no such showing in this case, nor was the post-hearing discussion transcribed.
http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/s67030_05.pdf
Appellant/father's due process rights were violated when the court in a dependency case added a provision to its order, ex parte, after the hearing, without giving father notice or an opportunity to be heard on the issue. The addition was a no-contact order concerning one of the witnesses.
An ex parte injunction can issue on where it is evident from the record that there would be immediate and irreparable injury if the injunction were delayed until notice could be given and a hearing held. There was no such showing in this case, nor was the post-hearing discussion transcribed.
Saturday, March 11, 2006
Pennsylvania Bulletin of March 11, 2006
The link http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/index.html
Of possible interest
- drivers licenses - occupation limited licenses
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/391.html
- recent statutes
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/387.html
- labor & industry - public comment on combined agency state plan - VR/OVR
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/403.html
- agriculture - referendum on continuation of state potato research program
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/393.html
Of possible interest
- drivers licenses - occupation limited licenses
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/391.html
- recent statutes
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/387.html
- labor & industry - public comment on combined agency state plan - VR/OVR
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/403.html
- agriculture - referendum on continuation of state potato research program
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-10/393.html
Monday, March 06, 2006
firearms - license - disclosure of social security number
Stollenwerk v. Miller, ED Pa. - February 24, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0225P.pdf
The court held that the state Uniform Firearms Act requirement that an applicant to buy or carry a handgun disclose his/her Social Security number is invalid under the federal Privacy Act, PL No. 93-579, sec. 7, 88 Stat. 1896, 1909 (1974), reprinted in 5 USC 552a note (2003).
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0225P.pdf
The court held that the state Uniform Firearms Act requirement that an applicant to buy or carry a handgun disclose his/her Social Security number is invalid under the federal Privacy Act, PL No. 93-579, sec. 7, 88 Stat. 1896, 1909 (1974), reprinted in 5 USC 552a note (2003).
Saturday, March 04, 2006
Pennsylvania Bulletin of March 4th*
Here’s the link
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/index.html
Of possible interest—
- IRRC – LIHEAP regs approved
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/369.html
- public utilities – telephone regs – petition of Consumer Advocate to amend chapter 63
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/358.html
* The only date which is a command
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/index.html
Of possible interest—
- IRRC – LIHEAP regs approved
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/369.html
- public utilities – telephone regs – petition of Consumer Advocate to amend chapter 63
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-9/358.html
* The only date which is a command
disability - consid. of evidence - duty to develop record - scope of magistrate judge's duty
Roman v. Barnhart - ED Pa. - February 28, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0248P.pdf
This case involves a 10 year-old boy with hearing and speech impairment. The case was remanded because ALJ did not explain his consideration of the records of the child's primary physician and "did not appear to give meaningful consideration to the non-medical evidence from [the child's] teacher...." This evidence was directed "to be evaluated and subjectively considered by the ALJ."
An ALJ need not always give a comprehensive explanation for the rejection of evidence. In most cases a sentence or short paragraph will suffice. Here however "it does seem to be an inescapable conclusion the ALJ did fail to directly address evidence from" the teacher.
The Magistrate's Report did discuss this evidence. However, in doing so, the Magistrate "exceeded her limited scope of review...[I]t is impermissible...to rectify ALJ errors by making an independent analysis and relying on information not relied upon by the ALJ....rather than focusing only on the reasons set forth by the ALJ."
There is also a good discussion of the ALJ's duty to develop the record adequately, even where the claimant is represented by counsel. When the ALJ is aware of a report that is "reasonably necessary for the full presentation of a case," the ALJ on his/her own initiative "may" issue subpoenas for the material documents.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0248P.pdf
This case involves a 10 year-old boy with hearing and speech impairment. The case was remanded because ALJ did not explain his consideration of the records of the child's primary physician and "did not appear to give meaningful consideration to the non-medical evidence from [the child's] teacher...." This evidence was directed "to be evaluated and subjectively considered by the ALJ."
An ALJ need not always give a comprehensive explanation for the rejection of evidence. In most cases a sentence or short paragraph will suffice. Here however "it does seem to be an inescapable conclusion the ALJ did fail to directly address evidence from" the teacher.
The Magistrate's Report did discuss this evidence. However, in doing so, the Magistrate "exceeded her limited scope of review...[I]t is impermissible...to rectify ALJ errors by making an independent analysis and relying on information not relied upon by the ALJ....rather than focusing only on the reasons set forth by the ALJ."
There is also a good discussion of the ALJ's duty to develop the record adequately, even where the claimant is represented by counsel. When the ALJ is aware of a report that is "reasonably necessary for the full presentation of a case," the ALJ on his/her own initiative "may" issue subpoenas for the material documents.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
disability - treating physician rule, etc.
Somenski v. Barnhart - ED Pa. - February 28, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0240P.pdf
Summary judgment for Plaintiff.
treating physician - phys. not an advocate; opinion based on objective evidence
Good review of 3d Cir. law on treating physician rule, which the ALJ improperly discounted. The ALJ erred in holding that the doctor's opinion was undermined by the fact that he "was an advocate" for plaintiff in a worker's comp. proceeding. The adversarial nature of W/C proceedings does not affect the reliability of the [doctor's] testimony. An ALJ "may not disregard medical findings of examining physicians merely because it was offered as part of a worker's compensation hearing..."
In addition, the physician's opinions were not based on the claimant's subjective complaints but on an objective, detailed assessment of Plaintiff's functioning.
finding of another agency
Plaintiff had been granted disability benefits by a US Dept. of Labor ALJ in a Longshoreman & Harbor Worker's Comp. case, 33 USC 901 et seq. While that decision is not binding, 20 CFR 404.1504, is "entitled to substantial weight....If the ALJ reaches a contrary conclusion, the ALJ must offer an explanation of why he rejected the other agency's finding." The ALJ in this case "did not specify what amount of weight, if any, he accorded the... decision not did he explain his reasons for rejecting it, beyond the fact that it was not binding. Under controlling Third Circuit law, this was error."
subjective complaints
Claimant's accounts of pain were corroborated by the unrebutted opinions of all physicians. Even though an ALJ's credibility determination is "entitled to great deference," subjective symptoms must be considered and "may not be discounted if reasonably consistent with the objective evidence and other evidence in the record." Here the ALJ improperly discounted unrebutted medical opinions and "erroneously supplanted" the doctor's opinions "with his personal speculation."
V/E - hypo
The hypothetical question to the vocation expert must fairly encompass "all of an individual's significant limitations that are supported by the record." (emphasis in original) The hypo in this case was lacking because if did not take into account the severity of the plaintiff's psych. problems or any of his exertional limitations.
remedy
Noting a) that the 3d Circuit has expressed "frustration with the delays in disability determinations," b) that plaintiff applied for benefits more than 8 years ago, c) that the extensive record is unlikely to change and "constitutes substantial evidence that [plaintiff] is precluded from engaging in substantial gainful activity," the court awarded benefits.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0240P.pdf
Summary judgment for Plaintiff.
treating physician - phys. not an advocate; opinion based on objective evidence
Good review of 3d Cir. law on treating physician rule, which the ALJ improperly discounted. The ALJ erred in holding that the doctor's opinion was undermined by the fact that he "was an advocate" for plaintiff in a worker's comp. proceeding. The adversarial nature of W/C proceedings does not affect the reliability of the [doctor's] testimony. An ALJ "may not disregard medical findings of examining physicians merely because it was offered as part of a worker's compensation hearing..."
In addition, the physician's opinions were not based on the claimant's subjective complaints but on an objective, detailed assessment of Plaintiff's functioning.
finding of another agency
Plaintiff had been granted disability benefits by a US Dept. of Labor ALJ in a Longshoreman & Harbor Worker's Comp. case, 33 USC 901 et seq. While that decision is not binding, 20 CFR 404.1504, is "entitled to substantial weight....If the ALJ reaches a contrary conclusion, the ALJ must offer an explanation of why he rejected the other agency's finding." The ALJ in this case "did not specify what amount of weight, if any, he accorded the... decision not did he explain his reasons for rejecting it, beyond the fact that it was not binding. Under controlling Third Circuit law, this was error."
subjective complaints
Claimant's accounts of pain were corroborated by the unrebutted opinions of all physicians. Even though an ALJ's credibility determination is "entitled to great deference," subjective symptoms must be considered and "may not be discounted if reasonably consistent with the objective evidence and other evidence in the record." Here the ALJ improperly discounted unrebutted medical opinions and "erroneously supplanted" the doctor's opinions "with his personal speculation."
V/E - hypo
The hypothetical question to the vocation expert must fairly encompass "all of an individual's significant limitations that are supported by the record." (emphasis in original) The hypo in this case was lacking because if did not take into account the severity of the plaintiff's psych. problems or any of his exertional limitations.
remedy
Noting a) that the 3d Circuit has expressed "frustration with the delays in disability determinations," b) that plaintiff applied for benefits more than 8 years ago, c) that the extensive record is unlikely to change and "constitutes substantial evidence that [plaintiff] is precluded from engaging in substantial gainful activity," the court awarded benefits.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
Thursday, March 02, 2006
real estate - sales - disclosure - adjacent group home
Colaizzi v. Beck - Superior Court - March 1, 2006
www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/a41023_05.pdf
Held, it was not a violation of the consumer protection law, 73 P.S. 201-1 et seq., or common law fraud for a seller of real property to fail to disclose to buyer that the adjacent property was the site of a group home for mentally-challenged adults.
Sellers signed a disclosure form under the Real Estate Seller Disclosure Law, 68 Pa. C.S. 7301 et seq., which said that he were not aware of "any condition that would affect the use and/or enjoyment of the property or the fair market value and/or title of the property." The appellate court reject that buyer argument that the lower court erred by focusing solely on the subject property rather than considering adjacent properties. The court said that there was no authority for such a reading of the law. "Moreover, even if we were persuaded by Appellant's argument, we find that the existence of a group home for mentally-challenged adults on the adjacent property does not constitution a 'legal issue'" under the RESDL.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/a41023_05.pdf
Held, it was not a violation of the consumer protection law, 73 P.S. 201-1 et seq., or common law fraud for a seller of real property to fail to disclose to buyer that the adjacent property was the site of a group home for mentally-challenged adults.
Sellers signed a disclosure form under the Real Estate Seller Disclosure Law, 68 Pa. C.S. 7301 et seq., which said that he were not aware of "any condition that would affect the use and/or enjoyment of the property or the fair market value and/or title of the property." The appellate court reject that buyer argument that the lower court erred by focusing solely on the subject property rather than considering adjacent properties. The court said that there was no authority for such a reading of the law. "Moreover, even if we were persuaded by Appellant's argument, we find that the existence of a group home for mentally-challenged adults on the adjacent property does not constitution a 'legal issue'" under the RESDL.
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
child witness - Tender Years Hearsay Act - psych. exam
Commonwealth v. Shearer - Superior Court - March 1, 2006
www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/e04010R_02.pdf
Superior Court reversed the trial court's order that a child-victim be examined by a private psychologist retained by alleged abuser prior to a competency determination by trial court under the Tender Years Hearsay Act, 42 Pa. C.S. 5985.1.
The appellate court said that it was "beyond doubt that a court-ordered psychiatric examination intrudes into an important aspect of human privacy concerns….While trial courts must regularly make competency rulings, a court-ordered psychological examination should never be the starting point for such a determination…..Such an examination should not be ordered unless the record demonstrates the existence of a 'compelling reason' for the examination….The fact that a witness is an alleged child victim of sexual abuse does not, in and of itself, negate the requirement of demonstrating the necessity for court-ordered psychological examination."
The court agreed with the Commonwealth that there was no evidence showing that the child witness "suffers from any mental condition that would require a psychiatric examination before a competency hearing can be conducted."
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Superior/out/e04010R_02.pdf
Superior Court reversed the trial court's order that a child-victim be examined by a private psychologist retained by alleged abuser prior to a competency determination by trial court under the Tender Years Hearsay Act, 42 Pa. C.S. 5985.1.
The appellate court said that it was "beyond doubt that a court-ordered psychiatric examination intrudes into an important aspect of human privacy concerns….While trial courts must regularly make competency rulings, a court-ordered psychological examination should never be the starting point for such a determination…..Such an examination should not be ordered unless the record demonstrates the existence of a 'compelling reason' for the examination….The fact that a witness is an alleged child victim of sexual abuse does not, in and of itself, negate the requirement of demonstrating the necessity for court-ordered psychological examination."
The court agreed with the Commonwealth that there was no evidence showing that the child witness "suffers from any mental condition that would require a psychiatric examination before a competency hearing can be conducted."
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
Wednesday, March 01, 2006
disability - depression - onset date - evidence
Payton v. Barnhart - ED Pa. - February 24, 2006
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0223P.pdf
The ALJ's determination of onset date in closed period case was inconsistent with the medical evidence and not supported by substantial evidence where the sole support of the ALJ decision was a "'non-examining' State Agency 'checklist.'"
The evidence showed that claimant's depression "did not suddenly become a severe impairment" on the date found by the ALJ but existed prior to that point, as established by the medical evidence.
The court reversed the ALJ decision rather than remanding the case, because the administrative record was "fully developed and…substantial evidence on the record as a whole indicates that the cliamant is disabled and entitled to benefits."
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions/06D0223P.pdf
The ALJ's determination of onset date in closed period case was inconsistent with the medical evidence and not supported by substantial evidence where the sole support of the ALJ decision was a "'non-examining' State Agency 'checklist.'"
The evidence showed that claimant's depression "did not suddenly become a severe impairment" on the date found by the ALJ but existed prior to that point, as established by the medical evidence.
The court reversed the ALJ decision rather than remanding the case, because the administrative record was "fully developed and…substantial evidence on the record as a whole indicates that the cliamant is disabled and entitled to benefits."
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
Friday, February 24, 2006
Pennsylvania Bulletin of February 28, 2006
Here's the link http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/index.html
Of possible interest-
- welfare - MA program fee schedule - procedure code changes
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/346.html
- attorneys - discipline - rules of disciplinary enforcement - amendments
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/322.html
- court rules - proposed - pleadings, format - comments due March 8th
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/323.html
- juvenile court judges' commission - statement of policy - admin. of restitution funds
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/329.html
- revenue - mystery multiplier bingo instant lottery game
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/348.html
Of possible interest-
- welfare - MA program fee schedule - procedure code changes
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/346.html
- attorneys - discipline - rules of disciplinary enforcement - amendments
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/322.html
- court rules - proposed - pleadings, format - comments due March 8th
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/323.html
- juvenile court judges' commission - statement of policy - admin. of restitution funds
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/329.html
- revenue - mystery multiplier bingo instant lottery game
http://www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol36/36-8/348.html
Thursday, February 23, 2006
custody - international - Hague Convention
In re Application of Adan - Third Circuit - Febrary 14, 2006
http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/053045p.pdf
District Court ordered return of parties' daughter to Argentinian father, whom appellant-mother had accused of abusing her and daughter. The 3d Circuit ordered a stay of the return order and remanded the case back to the district court -- which it said had created a "woefully incomplete" record -- for detailed fact-finding about the abuse, the ability of Argentinian authorities to protect the child, etc.
See also, Baxter v. Baxter, Third Circuit Court of Appeals, September 15, 2005 http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/043228p.pdf
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/053045p.pdf
District Court ordered return of parties' daughter to Argentinian father, whom appellant-mother had accused of abusing her and daughter. The 3d Circuit ordered a stay of the return order and remanded the case back to the district court -- which it said had created a "woefully incomplete" record -- for detailed fact-finding about the abuse, the ability of Argentinian authorities to protect the child, etc.
See also, Baxter v. Baxter, Third Circuit Court of Appeals, September 15, 2005 http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/043228p.pdf
Donald Marritz
MidPenn Legal Services
Wednesday, February 22, 2006
Class Action Notice Landscaping H-2B Case
To: Advocates for Workers
The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania nationwide FLSA opt-in class action notice on behalf of H-2B workers against The Brickman Group, Ltd. is available at the following web location:
http://friendsfw.org/H-2B/Brickman/Class_Notice.pdf
The consent form must be returned prior to July 15, 2006. A copy of the consent form is available for printing at:
http://friendsfw.org/H-2B/Brickman/Brickman_Consent.pdf
Brickman is one of the largest employer's of H-2B landscaping workers. The class includes more than 2,000 persons from Mexico and more than 100 persons from Guatemala. The lawsuit is based upon the continuing failure to comply with Arriaga, et al. v. Florida Pacific Farms, LLC, et al., 305 F.3d 1228 (11th Cir. 2002)
The Defendant's U.S. operations where in numerous different status. Addresses supplied as last known US addresses for foreign H-2B workers include persons in the following states (in declining numbers of persons for 2005) : MD; MI; PA; IN; MO; OH; NJ; VA; NY; CO; TX; CT; FL; DE; TN; IL; CA; MA; NC
Interested persons should contact Friends of Farmworkers staff attorney Manuel Boigues, mboigues@friendsfw.org, telephone (215) 733-0878, ext. 130.
Co-counsel include:
Edward Tuddenham
and
Rachel Micah-Jones
Centro de los Derechos del Migrante
Calle VÃctor Rosales #164
Col. Centro, Zacatecas, Zac., Méx.
C.P. 98000
Tel: 011 (52) 492 925 2510
Fax: 011 (52) 492 925 2511
Free call from Mexico 01-800-59-01-773
Free call within the US: 1 - (800) 401-5901
From: Art Read, Friends of Farmworkers
The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania nationwide FLSA opt-in class action notice on behalf of H-2B workers against The Brickman Group, Ltd. is available at the following web location:
http://friendsfw.org/H-2B/Brickman/Class_Notice.pdf
The consent form must be returned prior to July 15, 2006. A copy of the consent form is available for printing at:
http://friendsfw.org/H-2B/Brickman/Brickman_Consent.pdf
Brickman is one of the largest employer's of H-2B landscaping workers. The class includes more than 2,000 persons from Mexico and more than 100 persons from Guatemala. The lawsuit is based upon the continuing failure to comply with Arriaga, et al. v. Florida Pacific Farms, LLC, et al., 305 F.3d 1228 (11th Cir. 2002)
The Defendant's U.S. operations where in numerous different status. Addresses supplied as last known US addresses for foreign H-2B workers include persons in the following states (in declining numbers of persons for 2005) : MD; MI; PA; IN; MO; OH; NJ; VA; NY; CO; TX; CT; FL; DE; TN; IL; CA; MA; NC
Interested persons should contact Friends of Farmworkers staff attorney Manuel Boigues, mboigues@friendsfw.org, telephone (215) 733-0878, ext. 130.
Co-counsel include:
Edward Tuddenham
and
Rachel Micah-Jones
Centro de los Derechos del Migrante
Calle VÃctor Rosales #164
Col. Centro, Zacatecas, Zac., Méx.
C.P. 98000
Tel: 011 (52) 492 925 2510
Fax: 011 (52) 492 925 2511
Free call from Mexico 01-800-59-01-773
Free call within the US: 1 - (800) 401-5901
From: Art Read, Friends of Farmworkers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)